Chinese Buyer Makes a Partial Payment: Which Invoice, Interest or Principal Is Cleared?

A partial payment from a Chinese buyer does not always reduce the oldest invoice or the principal first. The contract, any allocation made when payment was made, and the applicable legal rules can produce a different balance. A foreign seller preparing a demand should explain how the receipt was credited, rather than simply deducting it from whichever invoice is convenient.
This guide addresses commercial goods-sale debts involving mainland China. It separates two questions: which of several debts is paid, and how money applied to a particular debt is divided between recoverable costs, interest and principal. If a specific balance is disputed, use the four-item enquiry outline below.
1. Establish the receipt, the debts and the governing rules
First verify that money was actually received, by whom, in what currency and on which date. A remittance instruction is not necessarily a completed payment. Reconcile any reversal, agreed credit or return before calculating the outstanding balance. See the payment-evidence checklist if the buyer says the account has already been settled.
List the actual contractual debts, not just the invoice numbers. Several invoices may document one obligation; one account may contain debts owed by different group companies. Civil Code Article 560 concerns several debts of the same kind owed by the same debtor to the same creditor. Do not pool an affiliate’s debt merely because its finance team sent the payment. Different currencies and third-party payments require their own examination of the agreement and legal effect.
The buyer’s location does not settle the governing law. Article 41 of the PRC foreign-related choice-of-law statute addresses contractual choice of law and the rule without a choice. Where the CISG governs the sale, review the contract and Convention first. Article 7(2) sets a sequence for resolving matters governed but not expressly settled by the Convention: its general principles, then the law determined by private international law if those principles are absent. The PRC domestic allocation rules below apply only where they govern the issue; they are not automatically imported into every China-related sale.
2. Read the agreement and the payment-time designation
Under Civil Code Article 560, the parties’ different agreement takes priority; otherwise, a debtor making an insufficient payment across qualifying debts may designate the debt it is performing at the time of payment. Check the signed contract, agreed account terms, later settlement and the complete payment correspondence. A seller’s internal rule to clear the oldest invoice is not necessarily an agreement between the parties.
Preserve the transfer reference and any accompanying email or remittance advice. A clear instruction identifying an order is different from a generic phrase such as payment for goods. Check who gave the instruction, whether it relates to this receipt, and whether the creditor acknowledged a particular allocation. A later unilateral spreadsheet should not simply be treated as a designation made at payment; a later agreement between both parties requires separate assessment.
Distinguish naming the debt from agreeing how its components are paid. A reference to Invoice B does not by itself resolve whether valid interest or recovery costs attached to that debt are paid before principal. Conversely, a mutually agreed principal-first arrangement should not be overlooked. If a receipt says full and final settlement, examine whether there was an effective settlement or release rather than treating those words as an ordinary bookkeeping label.
3. Without a designation, work through the statutory order
Where Article 560 applies and neither a different agreement nor a payment-time designation resolves the issue, the default order is not simply oldest invoice first. Follow each condition in sequence:
- Prefer debts that are already due.
- If several are due, prefer a debt with no security or the least security for the creditor.
- If none is secured, or the security is equal, prefer the debt more burdensome to the debtor.
- If that burden is equal, follow the order in which the debts became due.
- If their due dates are the same, allocate in proportion to the debts.
Compare the actual security and obligations; the invoice number or date printed at the top does not establish maturity, security or relative burden. A disputed penalty or an unverified guarantee should not be treated as an established priority fact. Record both the evidence and any point on which the parties disagree.
For a purely illustrative calculation, suppose two due debts of 6,000 and 4,000 units have no security, equal burden and the same due date. Assume no different agreement, no designation and no associated costs or interest. A payment of 2,000 would be divided 1,200 and 800 in that final proportional step, leaving 4,800 and 3,200. This is arithmetic under stated assumptions, not a client case or a prediction about a particular account.
4. Then distinguish recoverable costs, interest and principal
Civil Code Article 561 addresses a debtor who owes interest and relevant debt-recovery costs in addition to the principal, where the payment is insufficient. Unless the parties agree otherwise, it places relevant recovery costs first, interest second and principal third. Article 560 and Article 561 answer different allocation questions and should be applied to the established debts and components, not used interchangeably.
The rule does not itself create an entitlement to every collection expense, lawyer’s bill, contractual penalty or interest rate. Establish whether the component is owed, its legal or contractual basis and its supported amount. Do not relabel disputed damages as interest merely to give them priority. The unpaid-price interest guide discusses the separate basis and calculation issues. CISG Article 78 addresses interest on sums in arrears but does not, by itself, answer every rate or allocation question.
For a second hypothetical, assume one debt has 10,000 principal, 600 valid accrued interest and 200 recoverable costs, with no different agreement. A payment of 3,000 first covers 200 costs and 600 interest, leaving 2,200 for principal and 7,800 principal outstanding. The example assumes the interest and costs are established; it does not quote a fee or rate. Later interest must be recalculated against the legally appropriate remaining base and dates, not mechanically charged on the original principal after it has been reduced.
5. Produce an allocation schedule that can be checked
| Record | What it should show |
|---|---|
| Debt schedule | Contracting parties, order, currency, principal, maturity, security and any disputed component. |
| Payment evidence | Actual receipt, payment reference, contemporaneous designation and relevant acknowledgement. |
| Allocation basis | The agreement or each relevant statutory step, with supporting records. |
| Result | Amount applied to each debt and component, remaining principal, separate disputed items and calculation date. |
Keep the original ledger and make a dated reconciliation rather than overwriting the history. If the parties disagree, show the competing calculations and the facts causing the difference. A party’s accounting treatment is relevant evidence, but it is not automatically a binding amendment or proof that the legal balance is correct. Confirm any new allocation agreement clearly and check the signatory’s authority.
Partial payment, quality set-off and a negotiated reduction are different events. A claimed quality loss needs its own basis; see quality deductions from unpaid invoices. Bank charges and exchange differences also require separate treatment under the shortfall guide. Avoid recovering the same sum twice or assuming that acceptance of money necessarily waived every remaining claim.
6. Use the reconciled balance for the next recovery step
A focused demand can identify the orders, acknowledge receipts, explain their allocation and state the supported balance and any separately disputed amount. This makes it easier to decide whether the next step is obtaining missing evidence, negotiating a payment arrangement or considering the agreed litigation or arbitration route. See payment-default recovery options in China and instalment-payment arrangements.
Check limitation and other deadlines separately. A partial payment does not justify assuming that every debt in a multi-invoice account has been acknowledged or that every deadline has restarted. Where an enforceable judgment, award, insolvency process or a specific settlement already governs payment, review that instrument and the applicable procedural rules before using this ordinary-contract calculation.
Discuss a disputed goods-payment balance
- Seller and Chinese buyer named in the contract:
- Orders, currencies, due dates and amounts still claimed:
- Partial payment date/amount, payment reference and allocation disagreement:
- Outcome sought and any actual deadline:
If the link does not open a mail app, copy these four items into an email to panjianxing46@gmail.com.
A conflict and matter check comes first. The law firm confirms service scope and fees in writing before substantive review. An enquiry does not create an engagement or pause a deadline. Agree a suitable channel before sharing sensitive records; no recovery amount, result or completion time is promised.
Author: Jianxing Pan, lawyer and partner at Beijing Chang’an Law Firm, working in Beijing and Shenzhen.
Sources checked: 21 November 2026. PRC Civil Code, Articles 560–561, effective 1 January 2021; the foreign-related choice-of-law statute, Article 41, effective 1 April 2011. CISG text, Articles 1, 6, 7, 53, 59 and 78; check UNCITRAL status and declarations, including China’s entry into force on 1 January 1988 and its Article 1(1)(b) declaration. The Canadian legislative reproduction supplies treaty text, not a choice of Canadian law. Earlier transactions require the relevant temporal-law review. General legal information only. Cover: AI-generated conceptual illustration, not a real client or case photograph.