Goods Held in China for a Supplier’s Unpaid Freight: What Can a Foreign Buyer Do?
المقالات متاحة حالياً باللغتين الإنجليزية والصينية.

If a carrier or warehouse in mainland China refuses to release goods because your supplier has unpaid charges, first obtain the written reason for the hold, an itemised account and confirmation of who can authorise release. Paying the supplier’s purchase price does not by itself prove that freight was paid, that you own the goods, or that the holder has no right to retain them.
The immediate question is whether the hold concerns this shipment’s charges or the supplier’s other debts. The legal basis for retaining the goods and the supplier’s obligations to the buyer require separate examination. This guide addresses private commercial retention where the relevant PRC rules apply. Customs detention, a court seizure, overseas terminal charges and carriage governed by special maritime rules need separate analysis.
1. Identify the holder, the debtor and the particular charges
Establish the legal name of the entity actually holding the goods and whether it acts as carrier, warehouse operator or another intermediary. A freight forwarder that arranged transport may not control the warehouse gate. Obtain the goods’ location, consignment references, quantity and current condition, together with the operator’s stated release requirements.
Ask which entity owes each amount, under which contract, when it became due and how it relates to the retained goods. Separate freight for this consignment, storage incurred on these goods, a previous shipment’s unpaid account and charges claimed by a different company. Request the booking terms, invoices, storage tariff and calculation period. An account balance headed “supplier debt” is not a sufficient explanation.
Read the sale’s allocation of transport and storage costs as well as the transport or storage contract. A seller’s promise that freight is included helps assess the seller’s performance; it does not alone determine the independent holder’s rights or whether the buyer has undertaken a payment obligation to that holder.
2. Test the asserted lien: ownership alone may not resolve it
Under Civil Code Article 836, a carrier may retain the relevant transported goods for unpaid freight, custody or other charges owed by the consignor or consignee, unless otherwise agreed. Article 903 addresses retention for unpaid custody and other charges under a custody contract; Article 918 applies the relevant custody-contract rules to matters not provided for in the warehousing chapter. The operator’s role and the applicable contractual arrangement therefore matter.
The general lien rules in Articles 447–450 also require attention: lawful possession and a due unpaid debt; normally the same legal relationship, subject to the enterprise exception; any statutory or agreed prohibition on retention; and the value requirement where the retained property is divisible. A disputed invoice does not automatically defeat a lien, and an unpaid invoice does not automatically establish every condition for one.
Article 62 of the Supreme People’s Court’s security-system interpretation, Fa Shi [2020] No. 28, draws an important distinction. Subject to its conditions, it supports retention of lawfully possessed third-party movables for an unpaid due debt arising from the same legal relationship. A foreign buyer cannot therefore rely solely on “these goods belong to me”. For enterprise retention involving a different legal relationship, it supports the third-party owner’s request for return; it also limits that enterprise exception by reference to debts arising in continuing business operations.
Map the relationships using the actual documents. “Different shipment” and “different legal relationship” are not necessarily interchangeable. Establish ownership through the contract and the legally relevant delivery or possession arrangement, rather than a payment receipt alone. A foreign-law sales clause should not be assumed to settle every property or third-party retention issue. For the related tooling problem, see ownership and retention of buyer-owned moulds.
3. Keep the claim against the supplier separate from cargo release
Ask what the supplier promised: payment of specified freight, delivery at an agreed place, provision of release documents, or another performance. A valid right asserted by a carrier does not itself excuse the supplier’s own contractual breach. Conversely, a buyer’s claim against the supplier does not automatically oblige a separate warehouse to release the goods.
Where domestic PRC contract law governs, Civil Code Article 593 addresses a party’s liability for breach caused by a third person, while disputes with that third person are handled separately. Do not apply that provision without first checking the sales contract’s governing law and any applicable treaty rules. Identify the correct defendant, dispute clause and claim requirements for each relationship.
Request the supplier’s concrete release proposal and preserve rights concerning additional costs. A hold does not automatically entitle the buyer to terminate the entire sale or recover the full price. A refund requires its own contractual or legal basis and consideration of the goods’ status. See non-delivery and prepayment recovery; if the real obstacle is documentation, use the shipping-document dispute guide.
4. Build a short evidence table before negotiating payment
| Question | Records to obtain | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Which goods are held? | Inventory, carton marks, location, condition and operator confirmation | Connect the hold and any release to the actual purchase |
| Whose debt is asserted? | Contracting names, invoice, due date and itemised calculation | Separate this consignment from other accounts |
| What right does the buyer claim? | Sale contract, payment record, title terms and delivery or custody evidence | Assess ownership and contractual delivery rights separately |
| What is needed for release? | Written authority, agreed sum, release instruction and collection conditions | Avoid paying an intermediary who cannot secure handover |
Keep dated records of the first refusal, free-time expiry, daily charges, supplier responses and feasible alternatives. Distinguish ordinary freight already allocated under the contract from additional loss caused by a breach. Where domestic PRC law applies, Articles 584 and 591 address recoverable loss and reasonable mitigation. The existence of a storage invoice does not establish that every charge can be recovered from the supplier.
5. Document a release arrangement before paying a second time
If commercial urgency makes a negotiated payment worthwhile, seek a written arrangement identifying the goods, verified recipient account, exact charges being settled, release authority and the coordinated steps for payment and handover. Check that the actual holder accepts the arrangement, not merely that the supplier promises to arrange it. Record who will collect, when storage charges stop and how condition and quantity will be recorded.
State how the payment will be treated between buyer and supplier, including any agreed reimbursement or price adjustment, and which claims remain disputed. Avoid unintended guarantees, assumptions of the supplier’s whole account balance or broad releases. A reservation of rights is useful evidence but cannot by itself create a reimbursement entitlement or override an effective settlement.
Ask whether an agreed security arrangement or partial release is feasible; an offer alone does not secure acceptance. If sale, disposal or deterioration is threatened, preserve the notice and seek prompt advice on the appropriate claim or interim measure. Do not remove goods without lawful authority or assume that a demand letter guarantees release within a fixed period.
6. What to send for an initial China cargo dispute assessment
Start with four items: the supplier’s and holder’s legal names; the goods’ location and order value; the written reason for retention and amount demanded; and the outcome sought, with any genuine collection or disposal deadline. A short summary can come first. The sale, logistics documents, payment evidence and charge breakdown can then be reviewed after the initial conflict check.
A focused review can assess the claimed lien, the evidence needed for release, the supplier’s contractual responsibility and a documented negotiation or dispute route. Use the China cross-border trade dispute service, the contact page, or panjianxing46@gmail.com. The service scope, fees and engagement arrangements should be confirmed before representation begins. Contact does not itself create an engagement or guarantee release or recovery.
Official sources checked on 11 November 2026. The Civil Code took effect on 1 January 2021; the security-system interpretation took effect on the same date under Article 71. Older transactions require a temporal-law check. General information by Jianxing Pan, Partner, Beijing Chang’an Law Firm. The cover is an AI-generated conceptual illustration, not a real client, warehouse or case photograph.